Monday, February 25, 2013

In Defense of Seth MacFarlane

Seth MacFarlane, host of this year’s Academy Awards ceremony, nailed it!

Perhaps I’m biased, because I am a HUGE Seth MacFarlane fan.

Of course you are.

Whatever. MacFarlane is a versatile showman who shits comedy gold.

Best known as the man behind the animated adult comedy series, Family Guy, MacFarlane’s brand of humor pushes every envelope imaginable. On the show, he famously blends pop-culture references, political satire, and borderline obscenities to create intelligent comedy.

That’s right, I called Family Guy “intelligent comedy.”


Nothing (and no one) is off limits. Some of the best episodes involve off-color topics that other prime-time comedy shows wouldn’t dare touch. Last night, he brought that brand of humor to the doorstep of the Dolby Theatre and smacked everyone right across the face.

Judging by today’s headlines, reactions were mixed.

Some of the words used to describe MacFarlane's performance include, “sexist,” “inappropriate,” disgusting,” “hostile,” and “ugly.”

Seriously?

One “off-color” moment that MacFarlane’s detractors seem to be latching onto is his introduction to Quentin Tarantino's “Django Unchained,” which went as follows:

 
"This is the story of a man fighting to get back his woman, who's been subjected to unthinkable violence. Or as Chris Brown and Rihanna call it, a date movie."

Look, people have been making Chris Brown jokes ever since he first laid a finger on Rihanna and the jokes have become more severe since the pair reunited... and rightly so!

I’m not saying that I find humor in a piece of shit who beats up his girlfriend and I certainly don’t think it’s funny when someone clearly doesn’t have the strength to leave an abuser... but calling them both out on it?

I, for one, think that it IS okay to satirically criticize a violent homophobe. Let’s make that shitbag so uncomfortable that he’ll never show his face at another awards show. As for his victim? I believe that we should also be pointing fingers at her. Rihanna is a supposed “female role model” and she keeps going back into an abusive relationship with this jackwagon?

The other big buzz seems to be all about MacFarlane’s hilarious opening number, “We Saw Your Boobs,” in which he calls out female actresses who have exposed their tits in major motion pictures.

Dana Stevens from Slate notes that it was the start to a downhill slope of “defensive anxiety about the ascendant power of women.”

Seriously?

Let’s face it, Hollywood is “boob obsessed” and it is rare that a blockbuster movie (sans tits) gets any fucking recognition. I would argue that NONE of the movies listed in that opening number NEEDED a tit shot to be what they were.

In a pre-Titanic world, the PC police whined about gratuitous tit shots in film and now they have done a complete 180 saying that bearing the breast is empowering and should be encouraged as “art,” but if we (men especially) point it out or make fun of it, we are “degrading women.”

At least that’s how Amy Davidson of The New Yorker sees it.

What Davidson, Stevens and most of the other detractors fail to recognize is that the true butt of MacFarlane’s jokes was Hollywood itself, which is, after all, what an Academy Awards host is traditionally expected to do - make fun of the Hollywood machine.

It is amazing to me that, on the one hand, we fight for equality, empowerment, and acceptance, yet we get so uptight when someone points out our differences, our mistakes or our struggles through satire. Last night, MacFarlane left no stone unturned. He joked about race, religion, sexual orientation, men, women, and everything in between.

If that’s not equality, I don’t know what is.

How about you? 


Were you offended by Seth MacFarlane’s performance? 

Did you think it was over the top?

9 comments:

Kianwi said...

I wasn't offended. He didn't have me rolling on the floor laughing, but it's not my kind of humor. I don't love the Family Guy, but if they invited him to host the show, then obviously the producers were okay with his kind of humor at the Oscars. Because he did what he is known for.

And the boob song? What was sexist about it? We did see all of their boobs! It was funny.

And other than that, who cares?! He's super cute and that's what I was paying attention to :)

lily said...

Who the hell would hire Seth MacFarlane and then expect him NOT to act like Seth MacFarlane?

Everyone knows what they're getting with Mr MacFarlane and yes, for some the jokes were a bit near the knuckle but should anyone have been really surprised?

And man, what a singing voice. *slinks back off to lurkersville, from whence I came*

Blab said...

i agree w alloyuz. enjoyed every bit of it. i never saw the man before last night...i dont like family guy but would like to see more of him ..very good voice..obviously a creative talent..also his humor was subtly satirical and he is aware of the nuances ...not a sexist racist ..but an intelligent man

Angie said...

I'll be the first to admit that I'm not his biggest fan. However, I thought he was clever and I enjoyed it more than I thought I would. We are still talking about Seth and not Saturday night right? Okay just checking.

YzarC AmaM said...

Who is he?

Maple Syrup Land said...

My son and I were laughing our asses off...the boob song and the loser song at the very end were not only funny, but true!

If the Oscars wanted some g-rated, PC, bland-as-porridge comedian, they should have asked someone else to host...I personally found him to be a breath of fresh air in an otherwise blah show

Amy Boergesson said...

I enjoyed it. I caught the boob song at work and had it stuck in my head- giggling to myself all night. In addition to assisting guests at Walt Disney World, I answer the main line switchboard calls for ABC, many viewers were not amused. I snickered as I sent them to the Comment Line!

If you want 'intelligent comedy', check out his other show, American Dad!

Pickleope said...

I didn't watch (although I did look up the Boob Song on YouTube) but enjoy my ill-informed opinion anyway...
Why would he agree to do it? That's what I don't understand. It's a thankless job with zero upside. No matter how good you do, people are still going to say you sucked. I remember when Chris Rock and David Letterman hosted. I liked it, but in that room, supposedly they died. There's just no way to win with that crowd. So, when you are asked to host the Oscars, just say "no." (That's what Nancy Reagan was talking about, right?)

HeatherL said...

I didn't watch (no cable) but I don't think I would have been offended anyway. I've found that I can't take anything coming out of Hollywood very seriously. It's all about the "shock and awe" nowadays. I think the last time I actually watched an awards show was when Billy Crystal was hosting!